• TheMongoose@kbin.social
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    7
    ·
    1 year ago

    I kind of like it. Like, he’s spent his whole life preaching the Federation ideals, trying to be the best he can be, and after all that, it cost him his son. I know that means less for us who only heard about David in TWOK, but watching Strange New Worlds now and hearing him talk about being in a relationship with ‘Carol’, it actually kind of retroactively hurts, because we know how it ends.

    And it wasn’t death in battle in a dangerous job that David chose to do, he was murdered by a Klingon saving the life of someone Kirk hardly knows.

    He didn’t steal the Enterprise and go on a genocidal rampage of Kronos or anything either.

    You can’t expect the man to be a saint after all that. Sending him to be the ambassador to the Klingons was cruel on Starfleet’s part, even if Spock did vouch for him. Totally on point, seeing how they did the same thing to M’Benga, Chapel, Ortegas etc. after the Klingon war. But still. Cruel.

    And even after all of that, even after ‘let them die’, even after becoming the obvious suspect for the assassination of the Chancellor and being sent to Rura Penthe… he never actually DID become the monster. He was still the best of Starfleet.

    • Stamets [Mirror]@startrek.websiteOP
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      7
      ·
      edit-2
      1 year ago

      To be clear, I also like it and I agree with all of your points. My comment isn’t saying that I dislike the scene. It’s that it’s harrowing to see him say that which was presumably why the line was included the way that it was. Just have an emotional reaction to seeing a hero saying something so monstrous and with extreme venom.